VAR is Ruining Football: A Fan's Case Against It
The Video Assistant Referee (VAR) was supposed to be football's perfect solution. It was sold to us as the technology that would eliminate "clear and obvious errors" and usher in a new era of fairness. But as we get deeper into its use across major leagues, one question keeps popping up: Is VAR actually ruining the beautiful game?
For many fans, the answer is a resounding yes. While its intentions might have been good, VAR has introduced a host of new problems, stripping away the very essence of what makes football so special.
1. It Kills the Atmosphere and the Joy of Goals
This is perhaps the most common complaint from supporters who attend matches. A goal is scored, the stadium erupts, and you are ready to celebrate with your friends. But then… the referee puts a hand to his ear. The joyous moment of a goal is instantly replaced with a feeling of dread and uncertainty.
The long, often confusing, pauses to review a goal for a potential offside or handball kill the spontaneous celebration. The atmosphere goes from electric to silent as everyone holds their breath, waiting for a decision. It’s a moment that can be completely ruined by a millimeter-based offside call that the on-field linesman would have never seen. Football is an emotional game, and VAR is a direct attack on that emotion.
Explore the History of the Offside Rule in Football – How It Evolved Over Time
2. It Has Made Decisions More, Not Less, Controversial
VAR was meant to end arguments about refereeing decisions, but it has only created new ones. The idea of a "clear and obvious error" is subjective and open to interpretation. This has led to decisions that are even more confusing than the ones they were meant to correct.
- Subjective Calls: VAR has been used to review everything from penalty shouts to handballs, which are often not black-and-white. For example, a player's arm position can be interpreted differently by different officials, leading to inconsistent decisions.
- The "Micro-Offside": The use of VAR to rule out goals for fractional offsides has been a major source of frustration. Fans argue that a player's shoulder or heel being a few inches offside when the ball is played goes against the "spirit of the game."
In the end, we still have heated debates about a referee’s decision, only now it's about the VAR official in a studio somewhere, not the one on the pitch.
Explore the Top 10 Most Controversial VAR Decisions That Shook Football History
3. It Disrupts the Flow of the Game
Football is a fluid game with a natural rhythm. VAR interruptions break this flow and add significant time onto the clock. A simple check for a goal can take two or three minutes, leaving players standing around and spectators confused.
Your Complete Weekend Football Fixtures Guide – Don’t Miss a Match!
This constant stopping and starting affects the momentum of a team, especially one that is on the attack. It can turn a fast-paced counter-attack into a boring stoppage, benefiting the defending team and slowing the game down to a crawl.
4. It Undermines the Referee on the Pitch
The introduction of VAR has changed the role of the on-field referee. They are now seen by some as simply a "go-between" for the VAR official in a remote location. This can erode their authority and confidence, leading them to rely too heavily on the technology rather than their own judgment and experience. The VAR system also puts them under even more pressure, as they are now scrutinized not only for their original decision but also for how they use (or don't use) the VAR monitor.
Premier League VAR Accuracy Hits 96% – What’s Next for Football Tech?
The Verdict: VAR is a Flawed Solution
While proponents will point to the data showing increased accuracy, they often miss the point. Football isn't just about statistics; it's about drama, passion, and the human element. VAR has made the game more clinical, but also less human. It's a system that has sacrificed the soul of the sport for the sake of a perfection that is, in reality, unattainable. For many fans, a few bad calls a season were a part of the game. Now, we have a slower, less joyous, and arguably more confusing game, and that is a price that is simply too high to pay.